The Evaluative Context of Corporate Reputation: An Integrative Framework for Understanding The historical Contingency of Reputational Criteria

Halpern, Pablo
Corporate Reputation Review · Springer Nature · 2026-10-12 · DOI: 10.1057/s41299-026-00282-5

Abstract

This paper introduces the concept of evaluative context and argues that corporate reputation cannot be properly conceptualized without it. The literature has made notable progress in disentangling how reputation is formed, who judges, and the consequences that follow from that evaluation. At the same time, it has left out of the spotlight the fact that the criteria stakeholders use to assess organizations change over time: they are historically contingent, socially constructed, and continuously evolving. Ignoring this makes any true comparison of reputation across different points in time very difficult, if not impossible. What built reputation a decade ago may be irrelevant today, and criteria mostly invisible to stakeholders yesterday can become salient and robust reputational factors tomorrow. The implications run from how reputation is measured to how it is conceptualized. Drawing on an integrative review of over four decades of reputation scholarship, institutional theory, legitimacy theory, and the sociology of expectations, we develop the Evaluative Context Model of Corporate Reputation (ECMCR). In this model, reputation emerges from three interacting layers. Organizations emit signals, stakeholders evaluate them, and both processes unfold within the evaluative context, the historically situated and socially negotiated set of criteria that determines what counts as reputationally relevant at any given time. The main implication is that the structure of reputation, not only its outcomes, changes over time as evaluative criteria evolve. We develop seven formal propositions, discuss theoretical and practical implications, and outline a research agenda.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles