Clinical Validation of Artificial Intelligence–Based Cartilage Segmentation Predicting Knee Replacement

Felix Eckstein, David J. Hunter, C. Kent Kwoh, Wolfgang Wirth
Arthritis Care and Research · Wiley · 2026-11-16 · DOI: 10.1002/acr.80140

Abstract

Objective For cartilage morphology to serve as a scalable endpoint in clinical trials, analyses should be performed automatically without human interaction. To clinically validate artificial intelligence (AI)–based analysis, we studied cartilage loss from magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) before knee replacement. Methods Knee replacement cases between 36 and 60 months' follow‐up in the Osteoarthritis Initiative were matched with controls by age, sex, and radiographic status. Cartilage thickness was determined by sagittal double‐echo steady state (DESS) and coronal fast low‐angle shot (FLASH) MRI. Segmentation was performed with automated (AI‐based: DESS and FLASH) and manual (DESS) methods. Two‐year change before knee replacement was compared using Cohen's d, and the medial compartment was defined as the primary analytic endpoint. Results One hundred thirty‐two case and matched control knees (113 participants; 55% women; mean ± SD age 64.4 ± 8.6 years) had DESS, and 35 had FLASH in both the case and control knee. In case knees (DESS), automated segmentation revealed an medial femorotibial compartment cartilage thickness change of −263 μm (standardized response mean [SRM] −0.63) and manual analysis of −259 μm (SRM −0.64). In controls, the rate of change was substantially lower by either method, with the effect size similar for automated versus manual segmentation (Cohen's d −0.40 vs −0.35). With automated FLASH, the Cohen's d was −0.59 versus −0.30 by the manual method. Conclusion AI‐based cartilage segmentation performed at least as well as manual expert analysis in separating knees with subsequent knee replacement from controls. This was consistent across MRI acquisitions with different orientations and contrasts. The findings support automated MRI‐based cartilage morphometry as a scalable imaging biomarker associated with a clinically meaningful outcome. image

Read at publisher →

Similar articles