The social mystery effect: How social versus solitary consumption influences consumer preference for mystery products

Liu, Yanzheng, Ding, Ying
Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science · Springer Nature · 2026-10-01 · DOI: 10.1007/s11747-026-01191-z

Abstract

Despite the substantial practical and theoretical relevance of mystery products (i.e., items purchased without knowing their specific nature), research on consumer preference for them remains underexplored, particularly from a social interaction perspective. Across eight main studies and two supplementary studies ( N = 5,787), we demonstrate that social (vs. solitary) consumption increases preference for mystery products. This effect is supported by diverse methods, including large-scale survey, field observation, controlled experiment, and incentive-compatible design. A sequential mediation underlies this effect: social (vs. solitary) consumption enhances perceived social support, which reduces uncertainty avoidance, thereby increasing mystery product preference. We further identify three theoretically-grounded and marketing-relevant moderators. The social consumption effect emerges primarily with close companions, is attenuated when an active online community provides supplemental social support, and weakens when surprise-oriented advertising reduces consumers’ reliance on social support to cope with uncertainty. These findings provide actionable insights for the design and positioning of mystery product offerings.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles