Framing the metaverse: how firms disclose an emerging technology, and who prices it
Abstract
This study examines how listed firms framed the metaverse in their annual reports during the 2021 to 2025 hype cycle, and whether that framing carried information that investors priced. Using the SEC’s EDGAR full-text search, we identified every Form 10-K that mentions the metaverse and classified each disclosure passage as opportunity, risk or neutral framing with a transparent rule-based scheme, validated against two independent human coders (inter-coder Cohen’s κ = 0.74; classifier against the reconciled human standard, κ = 0.68). Three findings emerge. First, metaverse disclosure peaked in fiscal year 2022 and roughly halved by 2025, while artificial intelligence (AI) disclosure in the same filings grew almost four-fold; the contraction is specific to the metaverse. Second, framing is value relevant in a bounded way. Opportunity framing predicted a higher three-day filing-window abnormal return, and the effect survived a robustness battery and an AI placebo. Yet the effect is concentrated among small, illiquid issuers, absent before the filing and undetectable beyond the announcement window. This pattern is consistent with promotional framing earning a transient premium where retail attention and limits to arbitrage are strongest. Third, foreign 20-F issuers sustained promotional framing one to two years longer than domestic firms. We interpret the evidence through the lenses of management fashion and impression management and draw implications for the governance of emerging-technology disclosure.