CEO overconfidence and strategic novelty: Leader-filtered problemistic search under performance shortfalls

Liu, Ethan Xin, Song, Yuan, Zhou, Jie
Asia Pacific Journal of Management · Springer Nature · 2026-09-18 · DOI: 10.1007/s10490-026-10186-x

Abstract

Debate persists over how CEO overconfidence shapes strategic novelty, which comprises strategic change—temporal resource reallocation—and strategic distinctiveness—deviation from industry norms. Integrating upper echelons theory with the behavioral theory of the firm, we develop a leader-filtered problemistic search framework in which CEO overconfidence directs aspiration-based search toward novel strategic action. Opportunity-driven adaptive mobilization channels overconfidence into strategic change, whereas comparison-driven normative deviation channels it into strategic distinctiveness. Using Chinese A-share listed firms from 2012 to 2023, we find that CEO overconfidence is positively associated with both dimensions of strategic novelty. These associations are stronger when performance falls below historical or industry aspirations and weaker when board vigilance or institutional ownership is high. Our findings clarify how performance feedback activates the strategic expression of CEO overconfidence in a transition-economy context.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles