A dysfunctional family of export promotion service providers? Collaborative governance in a complex and fragmented regional network

Blackburne, Giles, Jiang, Chenhui, Liu, Yan Emma, McDonald, Frank, Wang, Mingchu, Wei, Yingqi
Journal of International Business Policy · Springer Nature · 2026-10-31 · DOI: 10.1057/s42214-026-00263-9

Abstract

En comparación con la formación y el desarrollo de políticas, la implementación de políticas de Negocios Internacionales ha recibido una atención académica limitada. Abordamos esta brecha examinando cómo se implementa la política de promoción de exportaciones a través de una red de promoción de exportaciones (EPN, por sus siglas en inglés) compuesta por proveedores de servicios de promoción de exportaciones heterogéneos e independientes que operan sin control jerárquico ni coordinación. Basándonos en el Marco de Gobernanza Colaborativa (CGF, por sus siglas en inglés), investigamos las condiciones de gobernanza que sostienen la implementación de políticas, centrándonos en la composición, la coordinación, la legitimidad y la rendición de cuentas. Utilizando un extenso estudio cualitativo de la EPN en West Yorkshire, Reino Unido, identificamos cinco temas interrelacionados: Desafíos, Competencia, Complejidad, Coordinación y Comunidad (las 5C, por sus siglas en inglés), a través de los cuales las condiciones clave de gobernanza colaborativa se hacen observables en la práctica. Aunque la EPN regional posee muchas características asociadas con una gobernanza colaborativa efectiva, las disfuncionalidades identificadas pueden obstaculizar una implementación eficaz. Presentamos posibles reformas que podrían mejorar la eficacia de la implementación de la política de promoción de exportaciones. Este estudio contribuye a la investigación sobre Políticas de Negocios Internacionales al demostrar cómo la gobernanza colaborativa, originada en las políticas públicas y la administración, puede diagnosticar fortalezas, debilidades y oportunidades de reforma en redes fragmentadas de promoción de exportaciones. Nuestro enfoque también puede contribuir al diseño de investigaciones sobre la implementación de políticas transfronterizas en diferentes contextos regionales y nacionales. Im Vergleich zur Politikgestaltung und -entwicklung hat die Umsetzung von politischen Maßnahmen im Bereich International Business in der wissenschaftlichen Forschung bisher nur begrenzte Aufmerksamkeit erhalten. Wir schließen diese Lücke, indem wir untersuchen, wie politische Maßnahmen zur Exportförderung durch ein Exportförderungsnetzwerk (EPN) umgesetzt werden, das aus heterogenen und unabhängigen Exportförderungsdienstleistern besteht, die ohne hierarchische Kontrolle oder Koordination agieren. Aufbauend auf dem Collaborative Governance Framework (CGF) analysieren wir die Governance-Bedingungen, die der Umsetzung politischer Maßnahmen zugrunde liegen, mit einem Fokus auf Zusammensetzung, Koordination, Legitimität und Rechenschaftspflicht. Anhand einer umfangreichen qualitativen Studie des EPN in West Yorkshire, Großbritannien, identifizieren wir fünf miteinander verbundene Themen: Herausforderungen, Wettbewerb, Komplexität, Koordination und Community (die 5Cs), durch die zentrale Bedingungen für kollaborative Governance in der Praxis sichtbar werden. Obwohl das regionale EPN viele Merkmale aufweist, die mit effektiver kollaborativer Governance assoziiert werden, könnten identifizierte Dysfunktionen eine wirksame Umsetzung behindern. Wir diskutieren mögliche Reformen, die die Effizienz der Umsetzung von politischen Maßnahmen zur Exportförderung verbessern könnten. Diese Studie leistet einen Beitrag zur Erforschung politischer Maßnahmen im Bereich International Business, indem sie aufzeigt, wie kollaborative Governance, die ihren Ursprung in der öffentlichen Politik und Verwaltung hat, Stärken, Schwächen und Reformmöglichkeiten in fragmentierten EPNs diagnostizieren kann. Unser Ansatz könnte auch die Gestaltung von Forschungsprojekten zur Umsetzung grenzüberschreitender politischer Maßnahmen in verschiedenen regionalen und nationalen Kontexten inspirieren. 与政策的制定和发展相比,国际商务政策的实施在学术界受到的关注较少。我们通过研究出口促进政策如何通过一个由异质且独立的、在没有层级控制或协调的情况下运作的出口促进服务提供者组成的出口促进网络(EPN)实施,来填补这一研究空白。基于协作治理框架(Collaborative Governance Framework, CGF),我们探讨了支撑政策实施的治理条件,重点关注组成、协调、合法性和问责制。通过对英国西约克郡出口促进网络的广泛定性研究,我们识别出五个相互关联的主题:挑战、竞争、复杂性、协调和社区(即“5C”),通过这些主题,关键的协作治理条件在实践中得以显现。尽管该地区的出口促进网络具备许多与有效协作治理相关的特征,但发现的功能失调可能阻碍政策的有效实施。我们讨论了可能增强出口促进政策实施效率的改革措施。本研究通过展示源自公共政策和行政管理的协作治理如何诊断分散的出口促进网络中的优势、弱点和改革机会,为国际商务政策研究做出了贡献。我们的方法还可能为不同地区和国家背景下跨境政策实施的研究设计提供启发。 Compared to policy formation and development, the implementation of International Business policy has received limited scholarly attention. We address this gap by examining how export promotion policy is implemented through an export promotion network (EPN) comprising heterogeneous and independent export promotion service providers operating without hierarchical control or coordination. Drawing on the Collaborative Governance Framework (CGF), we interrogate the governance conditions underpinning policy implementation, focusing on composition, coordination, legitimacy and accountability. Using an extensive qualitative study of the EPN in West Yorkshire, UK, we identify five interrelated themes: Challenges, Competition, Complexity, Coordination and Community (the 5Cs), through which key collaborative governance conditions become observable in practice. While the regional EPN possesses many characteristics associated with effective collaborative governance, identified dysfunctionalities may hamper effective implementation. We discuss possible reforms that could enhance the efficacy of export promotion policy implementation. This study contributes to International Business Policy research by demonstrating how collaborative governance, originating in public policy and administration, can diagnose strengths, weaknesses and reform opportunities in fragmented EPNs. Our approach may also inform research design on the implementation of cross-frontier policies in different regional and national contexts. Comparada à formação e desenvolvimento de políticas, a implementação de políticas de Negócios Internacionais tem recebido pouca atenção acadêmica. Abordamos essa lacuna examinando como a política de promoção de exportações é implementada por meio de uma rede de promoção de exportações (RPE) composta por prestadores de serviços de promoção de exportações heterogêneos e independentes, que operam sem controle ou coordenação hierárquica. Com base no Modelo de Governança Colaborativa (MGC), investigamos as condições de governança que sustentam a implementação de políticas, com foco na composição, coordenação, legitimidade e prestação de contas. Por meio de um extenso estudo qualitativo da RPE em West Yorkshire, Reino Unido, identificamos cinco temas inter-relacionados: Desafios, Competição, Complexidade, Coordenação e Comunidade (os 5Cs), por meio dos quais as principais condições de governança colaborativa tornam-se observáveis na prática. Embora a RPE regional possua muitas características associadas à governança colaborativa eficaz, disfuncionalidades identificadas podem prejudicar a implementação efetiva. Discutimos possíveis reformas que poderiam melhorar a eficácia da implementação da política de promoção de exportações. Este estudo contribui para a pesquisa em Políticas de Negócios Internacionais ao demonstrar como a governança colaborativa, originada na política e administração pública, pode diagnosticar forças, fraquezas e oportunidades de reforma em RPE fragmentadas. Nossa abordagem também pode servir de base para o desenho de pesquisas sobre a implementação de políticas transfronteiriças em diferentes contextos regionais e nacionais. This article explores how export promotion policies are implemented through networks of organizations, focusing on the governance of these networks. Export promotion is crucial for national growth and competitiveness, but existing research often overlooks how policies are put into practice. The study examines how the characteristics of export promotion networks (EPNs)—such as their composition, coordination, legitimacy, and accountability—affect policy implementation. The research focuses on West Yorkshire, UK, where export promotion is delivered through a network of diverse organizations without a clear hierarchical structure. This article uses a collaborative governance framework (CGF) to analyze the EPN in West Yorkshire. The CGF examines how multiple agencies can work together effectively without a central authority. The study employs a three-stage, multi-method approach: mapping the network of export promotion service providers (EPSPs), conducting interviews with representatives from these organizations, and holding a workshop with stakeholders. The research identifies five key themes, termed the "5Cs": Challenges, Competition, Complexity, Coordination, and Community. These themes help to understand how governance issues manifest in the EPN. The findings reveal that while the EPN in West Yorkshire has strengths, such as legitimacy and shared purpose, it also faces significant challenges. These include competition among EPSPs, complexity in navigating the network, and coordination issues. The study suggests that effective governance requires more than just competent providers; it also depends on how well these providers coordinate and collaborate. The research highlights the need for reforms to improve policy implementation, such as better information sharing, clearer roles, and stronger leadership. These changes could enhance the effectiveness of export promotion policies and provide valuable insights for policymakers and practitioners in other regions and countries. In conclusion, the study advances the understanding of how export promotion policies are implemented through networks of independent organizations. It emphasizes the importance of governance in ensuring effective policy delivery and suggests that collaborative governance can offer a viable alternative to hierarchical control. Future research could explore how these findings apply to other regions and policy areas, potentially leading to more effective and coordinated policy implementation globally. This text was initially drafted using artificial intelligence, then reviewed by the author(s) to ensure accuracy. Comparativement à leur formulation et à leur élaboration, la mise en œuvre des politiques relatives aux affaires internationales a reçu relativement peu d’attention dans la littérature scientifique. Nous contribuons à combler cette lacune en examinant comment les politiques de promotion des exportations sont mises en œuvre par l’intermédiaire d’un réseau de promotion des exportations (RPE) composé de prestataires de services hétérogènes et indépendants, opérant en l’absence de contrôle ou de coordination hiérarchique. En nous appuyant sur le Cadre de gouvernance collaborative (CGC), nous analysons les conditions de gouvernance qui sous-tendent la mise en œuvre des politiques, en nous concentrant sur la composition, la coordination, la légitimité et la reddition de comptes. À partir d’une étude qualitative approfondie du RPE du West Yorkshire, au Royaume-Uni, nous identifions cinq thèmes interreliés : les défis, la concurrence, la complexité, la coordination et la communauté (les « 5 C »), à travers lesquels les principales conditions de la gouvernance collaborative deviennent observables dans la pratique. Bien que le RPE régional présente de nombreuses caractéristiques associées à une gouvernance collaborative efficace, les dysfonctionnements relevés peuvent nuire à l’efficacité de la mise en œuvre. Nous examinons les réformes susceptibles d’améliorer la mise en œuvre des politiques de promotion des exportations. Cette étude contribue à la recherche sur les politiques relatives aux affaires internationales en montrant comment la gouvernance collaborative, concept issu des travaux en politiques publiques et en administration publique, permet de diagnostiquer les forces et les faiblesses des RPE fragmentés et d’identifier des possibilités de réforme. Notre approche peut également éclairer la conception de recherches portant sur la mise en œuvre de politiques transfrontalières dans différents contextes régionaux et nationaux.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles