The Co-evolution of sustainability signals under SFDR: evidence across asset classes in the Belgian UCITS fund market

Depaemelaere, Bart, Peeters, Michaël
Journal of Asset Management · Springer Nature · 2026-10-31 · DOI: 10.1057/s41260-026-00479-7

Abstract

As investors rely on multiple sustainability signals when assessing a fund, the alignment among those signals matters. As the regulatory framework evolves, we examine whether SFDR classifications become more coherent with other investor-facing signals, including ESG risk, SDG alignment, carbon intensity, governance indicators, and the Towards Sustainability label. The analysis covers UCITS funds marketed to Belgian investors from 2021 to 2025. We find mixed and complex results: coherence is clearer in the later regulatory phases, but not across the board. Results vary by indicator, asset class, and SFDR threshold. Reclassification results are uneven as well, with the clearest pattern observed for upgrades from Article 6 to Article 8. The longitudinal models reveal a stronger association between ESG and SDG characteristics and a higher SFDR positioning at the end of the phase. This is primarily during the Early and Post-clarification periods. The reverse association between SFDR evolution and subsequent ESG positioning is weaker and sensitive to baseline ESG persistence. Carbon and governance results show a similar asymmetric pattern. These findings support a qualified and asymmetric co-evolution interpretation, with temporal associations indicating that SFDR classifications and external sustainability signals are related over time rather than evolving entirely independently. Overall, SFDR classifications seem to be settling into a broader set of sustainability signals. What they contribute depends on the measure, the asset class, and the classification threshold. Clearer categories alone may therefore not be enough for reform if they do not align sufficiently with the other sustainability signals available to market participants.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles