More than words: how discrete emotions and image colorfulness influence the helpfulness of online reviews
Abstract
Helpful online reviews play a critical role in influencing consumer decision-making and driving sales on e-commerce platforms. While scholarly interest in the influence of emotional cues on review helpfulness has increased, extant research predominantly conceptualizes emotional content through broad negative or positive sentiment categories. This approach overlooks the role of discrete emotions, such as anger, fear, disgust, and sadness. Although these emotions share a negative valence, they differ in their psychological antecedents and in how they shape consumer interpretation. Treating them as a uniform category limits both theoretical nuance and practical insight into the mechanisms underlying review helpfulness. Drawing on emotional appraisal theory, we explore the direct and interactive impacts of negative discrete emotions on review helpfulness and the moderating impact of review image colorfulness. Using Amazon reviews as a data source, we find that anger enhances review helpfulness, while sadness and disgust diminish it. Additionally, review image colorfulness amplifies the effects of anger and disgust on review helpfulness. Theoretically, this study advances the literature by distinguishing the effects of negative discrete emotions and highlighting the role of image colorfulness in moderating the emotional impact. It also offers novel insights for platform designers and marketers by demonstrating how specific emotional expressions and visual cues jointly shape consumers’ perceptions of review helpfulness.