Systemic Research Design as a Reflexive Architecture: Repositioning the Research Onion and the System of Systems Methodologies

Nazari, Mohammadjafar
Systemic Practice and Action Research · Springer Nature · 2026-10-28 · DOI: 10.1007/s11213-026-09786-x

Abstract

Research design in complex social and organizational settings is a systemic practice in which boundaries, purposes, stakeholder relations, and methodological choices co-evolve. Yet mainstream research-design frameworks often represent these choices as nested or sequential, while systems methodologies are positioned inconsistently as philosophies, approaches, methodologies, or techniques. This article develops a reflexive architecture for systemic research design through a critical integrative synthesis of the research onion, the system of systems methodologies (SoSM), critical systems thinking, systemic intervention, multimethodology, boundary critique, and critical systems practice. The architecture repositions the research onion from a nested representation to five co-equal and recursively connected design domains; treats systemic practice as a cross-domain identity rather than an additional layer; and positions the SoSM as an external resource for comparison, critique, and methodological configuration rather than deterministic selection. Its evaluative core is reflexive coherence, operationalized through five criteria: boundary transparency, participation adequacy, methodological complementarity, consequence sensitivity, and documented redesign. Recursive review is neither infinite nor mechanically scored: design may be provisionally stabilized when these criteria have been explicitly examined, material tensions are defensible, and further revision is unlikely to yield a substantively better configuration relative to the inquiry’s purpose and constraints. The article therefore contributes more than a call for researcher reflexivity: it offers a meso-level architecture for sustaining coherence, legitimacy, and purposeful action as systemic research designs evolve. The claims remain conceptual and require comparative empirical testing in action research.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles