Discordance Between Japanese and European Definitions of Acute‐on‐Chronic Liver Failure in Alcohol‐Related Cirrhosis: Insights From a 10‐Year Consecutive Cohort

Hidehiro Kamezaki, Nana Yamada, Terunao Iwanaga, Takafumi Sakuma, Koji Takahashi, Junichi Senoo, Makoto Arai, Tatsuo Kanda, Sadahisa Ogasawara, Jun Kato
Hepatology Research · Wiley · 2026-08-24 · DOI: 10.1111/hepr.70264

Abstract

ABSTRACT Aim To examine concordance between the Japanese acute‐on‐chronic liver failure (ACLF) classification and the organ failure (OF)‐based European association for the study of the liver‐chronic liver failure (EASL‐CLIF) framework, and to clarify the medium‐term prognostic implications of discordance in alcohol‐related cirrhosis. Methods Adults with alcohol‐related cirrhosis were studied in a single‐center consecutive cohort. Japanese‐defined ACLF episodes were classified as confirmed (bilirubin plus coagulation criteria) or extended (either criterion alone), then cross‐classified by EASL‐CLIF grade. First ACLF episodes were analyzed for 1‐year mortality using Kaplan–Meier, Cox, and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analyses. Results Among 158 patients, 26 developed Japanese‐defined ACLF (30 episodes). Discordance was substantial: 66.7% of extended and 22.2% of confirmed episodes were EASL‐CLIF grade 0, not meeting EASL‐CLIF criteria. In the first‐episode cohort ( n = 26), 1‐year survival was 77.8% for confirmed and 69.5% for extended ACLF (log‐rank p = 0.692). Among Japanese‐defined ACLF episodes classified as EASL‐CLIF grade 0, the estimated 90‐day mortality was 0%, whereas the estimated 1‐year mortality was 21.4%. In exploratory ROC analyses, the model for end‐stage liver disease (MELD) showed the numerically highest area under the ROC curve for 1‐year mortality (AUC 0.797, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.627–0.967); however, pairwise AUC differences were not significant. Conclusions Japanese‐defined ACLF, particularly extended ACLF, often corresponds to EASL‐CLIF grade 0, yet discordant patients showed non‐negligible 1‐year mortality. These findings suggest that acute hepatic deterioration without overt OF may represent a clinically relevant early‐risk phase in alcohol‐related cirrhosis. Hepatic‐ and OF‐based frameworks should therefore be interpreted as complementary.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles