Patients Improve, Patterns Persist: Longitudinal Stability of Rheumatoid Arthritis Joint Involvement Patterns

Tjardo Maarseveen, Yasuo Nagafuchi, Kristina Lend, Seyam Alemyar, Herman Kasper Glas, Gerdur Gröndal, Bjorn Gudbjornsson, Espen A. Haavardsholm, Kim Hørslev Petersen, Jon Lampa, Merete Lund Hetland, Dan Nordström, Mike Nurmohamed, Mikkel Østergaard, Anna Rudin, Marte Schrumpf Heiberg, Tuulikki Sokka‐Isler, Till Uhlig, Josien van Dieren, Ronald van Vollenhoven, Tom Huizinga, Marcel J. T. Reinders, Sytske Anne Bergstra, Erik van den Akker, Rachel Knevel
Arthritis Care and Research · Wiley · 2026-11-13 · DOI: 10.1002/acr.80174

Abstract

Objective Rheumatoid arthritis is a heterogeneous disease. Data‐driven approaches, from synovial histology to joint involvement patterns (JIPs), have sought to define clinically meaningful subgroups. Whether these subgroups represent stable phenotypes or transient disease states remains unclear. We aimed to develop a novel analytical method to measure longitudinal stability of these subsets. Methods We analyzed two randomized controlled trials, Nordic Rheumatic Diseases Strategy Trials and Registries (NORD‐STAR; n = 630) and Behandel‐Strategieën (BeST; n = 445), and one real‐world cohort (Reumazorg Zuidwest Nederland [RZWN], n = 252), all treated with disease‐modifying antirheumatic drugs under a treat‐to‐target strategy. Patients were assigned to previously defined JIP subgroups based on shared clinical features. Disease progression was then tracked over one year along the two principal axes of JIP variation: overall severity (oligoarticular vs polyarticular) and anatomic distribution (hand vs foot). Longitudinal stability was assessed by measuring how phenotypically similar each patient remained to others sharing their initial joint pattern and was quantified using silhouette‐like scores. Results Effective treatment led to convergence toward mild disease. Nevertheless, patients sharing similar baseline JIPs maintained clustering together over time significantly more than expected by chance in BeSt ( P = 0.018–0.038), NORD‐STAR ( P = 0.004–0.017), and RZWN ( P < 0.001), except for J polyarthritis in BeSt and JIP in oligoarthritis in NORD‐STAR. When stratifying by anatomic region, we found that improvement in foot involvement lagged behind hand involvement across trials. Conclusion Patients with similar baseline JIPs maintain phenotypic similarity over time, suggesting JIP subgroups reflect distinct, stable phenotypes rather than transient disease states. Our tool is available to study the longitudinal stability of any subset.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles