Scandals as context-dependent entrepreneurial mechanisms: opportunity creation, legitimacy and the logic of succès de scandale

Grolleau, Gilles, Borin, Elena, Bienfait, Nathalie Schieb, Mosca, Michele
International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal · Springer Nature · 2026-09-12 · DOI: 10.1007/s11365-026-01247-0

Abstract

This article examines how scandals can function as context-dependent entrepreneurial mechanisms within creative and highly visible markets. Drawing on a constructivist and opportunity-creation perspective, the study moves beyond the traditional view of scandals as purely detrimental events and conceptualises them as ambivalent phenomena that may enable or constrain entrepreneurial action. A two-dimensional framework is developed to distinguish scandals according to their domain of origin (artistic versus private) and their intentionality (self-inflicted versus externally triggered). Building on illustrative case evidence, the paper develops a conceptual explanation of how scandals can mobilise attention, reshape stakeholder perceptions, and influence legitimacy dynamics, thereby affecting opportunity creation, identity construction, and market positioning. Particular attention is devoted to the notion of succès de scandale, through which actors operate as norm entrepreneurs, deliberately engaging in boundary-breaking behaviours to gain visibility and accelerate recognition. The findings highlight that the entrepreneurial outcomes of scandals depend on the interplay between narrative control, audience alignment, and institutional responses. By articulating a set of propositions, this study contributes to the entrepreneurship and management literature by advancing a more nuanced understanding of how controversy can be strategically enacted, appropriated, or resisted within entrepreneurial processes. The paper also provides managerial implications for navigating reputational dynamics in environments characterised by high media exposure and evolving legitimacy expectations.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles