We study how TikTok affects demand for music on paid streaming platforms in the context of Universal Music Group’s (UMG) global withdrawal of its catalog from TikTok. Recent studies using this quasi-natural experiment have reached different conclusions about whether TikTok promotes or cannibalizes streaming demand. We show that these differences arise in part because the estimand changes with the specification. With heavy-tailed outcomes, common difference-in-differences implementations in levels, logs, and Poisson place weight on different parts of the distribution and therefore answer different economic questions. In our data, the top 10% of songs account for 96% of TikTok creations and 76% of Spotify streams, making the distinction between the typical song and the economically consequential song central. We find that removing TikTok access lowers aggregate Spotify demand for UMG titles. The losses are concentrated among viral songs, while the long tail shows little economically meaningful change. Evidence from the 2025 U.S. TikTok outage, which disrupted TikTok access across labels rather than for UMG alone, points in the same direction. Finally, we show that lost TikTok exposure reduces playlist inclusion, compounding the initial demand shock into longer-term declines in streaming demand. We also provide a practitioner’s companion that guides the choice of DiD estimands, estimators, and diagnostics in heavy-tailed outcome settings, along with an interactive tool at DiDestimands.app .
Winkler, Daniel, Hotz-Behofsits, Christian, Wlömert, Nils et al. Does TikTok promote or cannibalize music streaming? Estimands and identification with heavy-tailed outcomes. // Quantitative Marketing and Economics. – 2026. – DOI: 10.1007/s11129-026-09312-2. – URL: http://link.springer.com/openurl/fulltext?id=doi:10.1007/s11129-026-09312-2
Winkler, Daniel, Hotz-Behofsits, Christian, Wlömert, Nils, Papies, Dominik, Liaukonytė, & Jūra (2026). Does TikTok promote or cannibalize music streaming? Estimands and identification with heavy-tailed outcomes. Quantitative Marketing and Economics. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11129-026-09312-2
Winkler, et al. “Does TikTok promote or cannibalize music streaming? Estimands and identification with heavy-tailed outcomes.” Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 2026. doi:10.1007/s11129-026-09312-2.
@article{Winkler2026,
title = {Does TikTok promote or cannibalize music streaming? Estimands and identification with heavy-tailed outcomes},
author = {Winkler and Daniel and Hotz-Behofsits and Christian and Wlömert and Nils and Papies and Dominik and Liaukonytė and Jūra},
journal = {Quantitative Marketing and Economics},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.1007/s11129-026-09312-2},
url = {http://link.springer.com/openurl/fulltext?id=doi:10.1007/s11129-026-09312-2}
}
The rising popularity of digital wealth management platforms (DWPs) has transformed how retail investors manage their portfolios. This study examines key factors related to the successful adoption of DWPs and their outcomes, using an...
Much academic research is focused on the application of predictive data, forecasts, and models to inform practical marketing decision-making. Such work offers powerful insights to marketers directing their firms and interacting with the...
Migrant tourism entrepreneurs (MTEs) are emerging as important actors in rural destination branding. However, the mechanisms through which they shape brand formation through everyday practices remain insufficiently understood. Drawing...
Authenticity drives customer decision-making and firm success, yet research remains fragmented due to the diversity of conceptualizations, mediators and outcomes, and empirical contexts investigated. Utilizing the entity–referent...
Signaling theory predicts that communication, such as by CEOs, might complement observable environmental engagement by a firm, by reducing information asymmetry. Yet it remains unclear whether firms with stronger environmental...