Hatchling counts: far from being perfect, but still a valid proxy
Abstract
Norris ( 2025 ) criticized the Amazon Turtle Program (PQA) and challenged the results and interpretations of Lacava et al. ( 2025 ). Here, we clarify some issues raised by Norris and show that the criticisms can be overcome. We demonstrate how specific biological characteristics of the species enable the number of hatchlings to serve as a valid proxy for population trends. We also explain the data-collection effort over 40 years of monitoring. We acknowledge both its limitations and potential. We reaffirm that the statistical analysis was appropriate for the intended purpose. Finally, we agree that caution should be exercised when claiming that the species is recovering. However, we must recognize the positive results in some areas and better understand what is happening in areas where a decline is underway.