The Function of the Sign and the Specification of Explanatory Questions

Queiroz, Joao
Biosemiotics · Springer Nature · 2026-11-20 · DOI: 10.1007/s12304-026-09676-8

Abstract

What is the function of a sign? Under-specified functional questions leave indeterminate what counts as an acceptable explanation, what mechanisms are relevant, and what standards of explanatory adequacy should apply. Drawing on contemporary philosophy of science and philosophy of biology, this paper argues that functional discourse in semiotics can conflate three distinct explanatory projects: (1) constitutive questions regarding what makes something operate as a sign, (2) organizational questions regarding how signs contribute to ongoing systemic or cognitive capacities, and (3) etiological questions regarding why semiotic systems are historically and evolutionarily retained. Using vervet monkey alarm calls, I demonstrate how a sign system enters three distinct explanatory projects depending on the explanandum under consideration.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles