Medical Science Educator Education

Teaching Research Ethics through Historical Controversy: IRB Simulation in Health Professions Education

Jackson, Kristopher, Desroches, Melissa
Springer Nature · 2026-12-01 · DOI 10.1007/s40670-026-02922-1

Abstract

Research ethics education often relies on didactic instruction that fails to convey the urgency and real-world complexity of ethical decision-making. This manuscript describes an IRB simulation grounded in Kolb’s Experiential Learning and Mezirow’s Transformative Learning theories. Working as simulated IRB panels, undergraduate nursing students unknowingly evaluated the 1996 trovafloxacin clinical trial, applying the Declaration of Helsinki and Belmont Report principles. Students assessed the adequacy of informed consent, vulnerable population protection, risk-benefit proportionality, and regulatory oversight based on documented trial events compiled by the instructor. A deliberate disclosure moment revealed that students’ ethical analysis addressed actual harm to real children, creating what Mezirow termed a “disorienting dilemma” to facilitate critical reflection. While implemented in an undergraduate nursing course, this activity could be implemented across disciplines, educational levels, and student backgrounds and may help transform ethics curricula into a more formative professional experience.

Read at publisher →