An analytics-based assessment of sales channel portfolios and revenue performance under disruption and recovery
Abstract
This study develops an analytics-based framework to evaluate how sales channel portfolios influence firm revenue performance under disruption and recovery. Using quarterly data from 84 U.S. manufacturing firms from Q4 2019 to 2023, we apply association rule mining to identify recurrent patterns linking channel configurations, product characteristics, and cross-channel fulfillment mechanisms to revenue outcomes. This approach enables the detection of complex, time-varying relationships difficult to capture using conventional econometric models. Retailer-based portfolios are consistently associated with stronger revenue performance across both phases, while online channel effectiveness varies by product type and portfolio structure. Physical store and outlet channels are more frequently linked to weaker outcomes. During recovery, online channels exhibit more stable positive associations, and outlet channels are associated with improved performance primarily for search products. Buy-online-pickup-in-store and curbside fulfillment mechanisms display limited and inconsistent revenue effects. The findings indicate a structural shift in channel portfolio strategies, from concentrated and hybrid configurations under disruption toward broader multichannel portfolios during recovery, consistent with a pattern of simplification followed by reconfiguration. By demonstrating how association rule mining can uncover channel-performance patterns, this study contributes to marketing analytics research and provides decision-support insights for managers seeking to design resilient, data-driven omnichannel strategies.