This research examines how recommender type (AI vs. human) interacts with recommendation set size (large vs. small) to shape consumers’ intention to choose from a recommendation set. Across three preregistered studies, a reversal effect emerges: Consumers are more likely to choose from a large (vs. small) recommendation set when the recommender is an AI agent, but from a small (vs. large) recommendation set when the recommender is a human agent (Study 1). This interaction is driven by perceived expertise. Specifically, larger (smaller) sets signal greater breadth (depth) of expertise for AI (human) recommenders, thereby increasing consumers’ likelihood of choosing from the recommendation set. Evidence for this mechanism is provided by mediation analyses (Study 2) and a moderation-of-process design (Study 3) that manipulates perceived benefits of knowledge-breadth vs. knowledge-depth. These findings offer actionable guidance for designing effective recommendation systems.
Zhao, Xiaohong, Chen, Binglin, Yang, Zhiyong. When does size matter? Divergent effects of recommendation set size in AI versus human recommenders. // Marketing Letters. – 2026. – DOI: 10.1007/s11002-026-09826-5. – URL: http://link.springer.com/openurl/fulltext?id=doi:10.1007/s11002-026-09826-5
Zhao, Xiaohong, Chen, Binglin, Yang, & Zhiyong (2026). When does size matter? Divergent effects of recommendation set size in AI versus human recommenders. Marketing Letters. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11002-026-09826-5
Zhao, et al. “When does size matter? Divergent effects of recommendation set size in AI versus human recommenders.” Marketing Letters, 2026. doi:10.1007/s11002-026-09826-5.
@article{Zhao2026,
title = {When does size matter? Divergent effects of recommendation set size in AI versus human recommenders},
author = {Zhao and Xiaohong and Chen and Binglin and Yang and Zhiyong},
journal = {Marketing Letters},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.1007/s11002-026-09826-5},
url = {http://link.springer.com/openurl/fulltext?id=doi:10.1007/s11002-026-09826-5}
}
The rising popularity of digital wealth management platforms (DWPs) has transformed how retail investors manage their portfolios. This study examines key factors related to the successful adoption of DWPs and their outcomes, using an...
Much academic research is focused on the application of predictive data, forecasts, and models to inform practical marketing decision-making. Such work offers powerful insights to marketers directing their firms and interacting with the...
Migrant tourism entrepreneurs (MTEs) are emerging as important actors in rural destination branding. However, the mechanisms through which they shape brand formation through everyday practices remain insufficiently understood. Drawing...
Authenticity drives customer decision-making and firm success, yet research remains fragmented due to the diversity of conceptualizations, mediators and outcomes, and empirical contexts investigated. Utilizing the entity–referent...
Signaling theory predicts that communication, such as by CEOs, might complement observable environmental engagement by a firm, by reducing information asymmetry. Yet it remains unclear whether firms with stronger environmental...