Dancing on Muddy Ground: The Challenge of Maintaining a Strong Reputation in a Changing Environment

Herbst-Lucke, Stephanie, Mayberry, Robert
Corporate Reputation Review · Springer Nature · 2026-10-17 · DOI: 10.1057/s41299-026-00274-5

Abstract

Organizational reputations of public and non-profit entities are dynamic and multidimensional phenomena that vary across different audience groups, creating a challenging environment for administrators. We conducted 82 in-depth interviews with top-level decision-makers in collegiate athletics to better understand reputational issues during times of field-wide volatility. Results highlighted the importance of mission valence as an important but overlooked reputational dimension. Environmental volatility drove agencies to emphasize outcome-oriented dimensions rather than process, and short- rather than long-term reputational goals. We identified the centrality of peer audiences from other agencies, an audience that defies the traditional internal/external dichotomization of reputation. Our findings show how, in a landscape of interdependent agencies, shifting goals and norms illustrate the complexity of reputation management for the public administrator.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles