Examining the role of consumer need in online product reviews
Abstract
Online consumer reviews are a vital source of market insight, yet existing research largely assumes that reviews reflect only post-consumption evaluations. This study challenges that assumption by revealing that pre-consumption factors, specifically consumers’ self-disclosed needs, play a decisive role in shaping both how reviews are written and how they are perceived. Drawing on person–environment fit theory, we examine how the (mis)alignment between consumer needs and product functions—referred to as consumer–product (mis)match—influences the content and linguistic characteristics of online reviews and their impact on satisfaction and perceived helpfulness. Using text-mining and econometric analyses of reviews from The Body Shop, we find that incorporating pre-consumption needs provides a more complete understanding of review behavior. Consumers with explicit needs write more detailed and diagnostic reviews, while need–function alignment leads to lower linguistic diversity, higher readability, and reduced subjectivity. Moreover, need–function mismatches moderate how review characteristics reflect both reviewer satisfaction and reader judgments of helpfulness. By linking pre- and post-consumption perspectives, this study reframes online reviews as cognitive and linguistic manifestations of expectation confirmation and disconfirmation. The findings offer actionable insights for businesses to better capture, interpret, and respond to consumer needs in designing products and managing online review systems.