Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy Clinical Psychology

Technical and Thematic Variability Among Therapist‐Trainees During Jail‐Based Psychotherapy: An Entropy‐Based Analysis

Jeremy J. Coleman, Emma Freetly Porter, Matteo Bugatti, JiSoo Park, Sabina Musliu, Jesse Owen
Wiley · 2026-11-01 · DOI 10.1002/cpp.70360

Abstract

ABSTRACT Therapists' ability to vary in their approach to treatment is considered central to responsive psychotherapy, yet little is known about how variability operates in jail‐based treatment, where client needs and institutional constraints shift rapidly. In this study, Shannon's entropy was used to quantify therapist‐trainee technical and thematic variability, and associations with multidimensional client outcomes were explored. Data were drawn from 671 psychotherapy sessions delivered by 21 therapist‐trainees to 138 clients in two jail settings. Clients completed the Clinically Adaptive Multidimensional Outcome Survey (CAMOS) each session, and trainees documented techniques and session themes. Multilevel models tested whether within‐ and between‐therapist entropy predicted posttreatment distress ratings of CAMOS domains, controlling for pretreatment distress and number of sessions. Pretreatment distress and number of sessions were the most consistent predictors of outcomes. Within‐therapist entropy was not associated with outcomes. Between‐therapist technical entropy did not consistently predict posttreatment distress, but moderated associations between pretreatment and posttreatment distress across psychological, relational, physical and spiritual domains. Greater between‐therapist technical entropy also attenuated the negative association between number of sessions attended and posttreatment psychological and relational distress. Between‐therapist thematic entropy was associated with lower physical distress and a stronger negative association between sessions attended and final ratings of physical distress. In jail‐based psychotherapy, therapist‐trainee variability was not uniformly associated with posttreatment distress but moderated associations between pretreatment severity, number of sessions attended and outcomes. Findings support distinguishing observed variability from clinically responsive flexibility and emphasize training and supervision models that cultivate broader clinical repertoires while underscoring intentional, context‐responsive variability in constrained treatment settings.

Read at publisher →