Mate choice: the biggest decision of all

Schlupp, Ingo
acta ethologica · Springer Nature · 2026-06-09 · DOI: 10.1007/s10211-026-00493-3

Abstract

Mate choice is among the most consequential decisions organisms make, with profound implications for individual fitness, population dynamics, and evolutionary trajectories. Since Darwin’s foundational work on sexual selection, research on mate choice has expanded enormously, yet some conceptual, empirical, and methodological challenges remain. In this review, I synthesize key themes in the contemporary study of mate choice, with particular emphasis on female and male choice, mutual selection, and the dynamic interplay between the sexes. I highlight a few persistent biases in the literature, including strong taxonomic skew, and a focus on sensory modalities and experimental designs that are intuitive to humans but may poorly reflect the perceptual worlds of other organisms. I discuss the costs and benefits of mate choice and emphasize the importance of social information and environmental context in shaping mating decisions. Methodological approaches, especially binary choice tests, are critically evaluated with respect to their strengths, limitations, and biological realism. I further explore the broader consequences of mate choice, including its roles in reproductive isolation, hybridization, and speciation. Finally, I identify key open questions and promising future directions, ranging from the integration of neurobiology, genomics, and cognition to the impacts of environmental change and the potential roles of deception and individual variation. Together, this review argues for a more integrative approach to mate choice, recognizing it as a dynamic process embedded in complex ecological and social systems.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles