Criminal Law Forum
Publisher: Springer Nature · ISSN 1046-8374,1572-9850 · 25 articles
-
Why Don’t Younger Solicitors Choose Criminal Legal Aid? Insights from the Theory of Planned Behaviour
The decline of younger solicitors entering criminal legal aid threatens the sustainability of the criminal defence profession in England and Wales. This study applies the Theory of Planned Behaviour to examine whether commonly cited...
- Reviewing: Mark Drumbl and Barbora Hola, Informers Up Close: Stories from Communist Prague (Oxford University Press, 2024), 252 pp., ISBN 978-0-19-285513-8
-
Advancing Visually Impaired Employees’ Access to Justice in Workplace-Related Sexual Offence Cases by Admitting Evidence Based On Their Identification of Perpetrators Through Smell in South Africa
Notwithstanding the international protections afforded by Articles 13 and 16 of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD), visually impaired persons often remain excluded from meaningful access to justice within...
-
The Effect of Legal Representation on Sentence Length in Ecuador: Public Defenders vs. Private Attorneys
This research paper examines the effect of the type of legal representation -public versus private- on the length of sentences in the Ecuadorian criminal justice system. Utilizing data from the 2022 penitentiary census, which provides...
-
Obligations to Protect Mental Integrity: Improving State Compliance by Criminalising Coercive Control?
Positive obligations arising from human rights instruments require states to provide criminal law protection to individuals’ mental integrity against psychological violence. These obligations suggest a close connection between...
-
Corporate Criminal Liability in Global Value Chains: Transnational Responsibility and Doctrinal Alignment
Global value chains have transformed corporate activity into a transnational enterprise, while systems of criminal liability remain largely confined within national boundaries. This article examines the resulting accountability gap...
-
Strengthening the Criminal Justice Response to Domestic Violence Through a New Offence of Coercive Control? The Queensland Experience
Traditionally, mainstream criminal law discourse has associated domestic violence most closely with physical violence. Feminist jurisprudential approaches, however, have long emphasised coercion and non-physical abuse in domestic...
-
THE DYADIC TENSION OF JUSTICE: INTEGRATING VICTIMS’ NARRATIVES IN PROCEEDINGS AT THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT
The International Criminal Court (ICC) faces the critical challenge of balancing its mandate to adjudicate individual criminal responsibility by integrating victims’ narratives into its proceedings. While the ICC readily incorporates...
-
‘Discovering What Survives Translation True?’: The Defence of Duress at the International Criminal Court
The question of when an individual ought to be able to plead the defence of duress in respect of serious violations of international criminal law has not been resolved by the decision to include a form of duress in the Rome Statute. The...
-
Suspended Prison Sentences in Czechia: How They Came to Dominate the Penal Landscape and Their Consequences
Suspended prison sentences are the most commonly imposed sanction type in the majority of post-communist European countries. In Czechia, they began to be widely used within a year after they were first introduced in 1919 despite having...
-
Stigma, Labelling, and “Corporate Psychopaths”: A Legal Perspective
This paper presents a novel argument proposing greater recognition of the stigmatic nature of the ‘psychopath’ label in the corporate crime context, particularly in relation to its use within academic research and in criminal judgments....
-
Will You Sweep Away the Righteous with The Wicked?’ Third-Party Rights in Forfeiture Law
Forfeiture, a potent tool in law enforcement’s battle against crime, especially organized activities, raises a legal conflict involving third parties’ rights. This includes the offender’s family, investors, creditors, property owners,...
-
THE DEFENCE OF DURESS: INCONSISTENT INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT RULINGS AND NATIONAL LAW GUIDANCE
This article explores how national law principles can address inconsistencies in the application of the defence of duress at the International Criminal Court (ICC). The Rome Statute is the first to codify this defence, but its...
-
Reconceptualizing Incomplete Attempt
Incomplete attempt laws are typically explained as laws that exist to justify timely law enforcement intervention. Such explanations may well provide good reasons for the laws based on harm prevention rationales, but they do not address...
- CONFERENCE REPORT:‘BLAME FOR IGNORANCE? PERSPECTIVES ON WILFUL BLINDNESS AND MISTAKES OF FACT’
- BOOKS RECEIVED
-
SENTENCING OFFENDERS THE RIGHT WAY: ON THE IMPORTANCE OF RELATING PENAL THEORY AND PENAL PRACTICE
The ethics of punishment constitutes an area of research that has recently been through a significant expansion, both in breadth and depth. But why is such research important? And how can it be conducted in the most fruitful way? In...
-
Sentencing procedures under the adversarial and inquisitorial models of justice: a comparative analysis
This article examines the key procedural distinction in sentencing between adversarial (common law) and inquisitorial (civil law) systems: bifurcation versus unification. Common law jurisdictions separate sentencing from the trial...
-
THE LEGITIMACY OF CRIMINAL LAW AND THE PERFORMANCE CRISES OF PENALITY
The legitimacy of state punishment has long been debated to justify the extreme form of government-authorized coercion that is criminal law. Rather than focusing on the abstract legitimacy of criminal law, this article examines another...
-
Tonry’s Blueprint for the Comparative Study of Sentencing Law and Policy
This essay explores Michael Tonry’s treatment of sentencing law and policy within the U.S. as an inherently comparative project. The essay draws from Tonry’s “early period” in comparative sentencing from the late 1970s to the middle...
- Introduction: Celebrating the Career of Michael Tonry
-
Incarceration and Crime Trends: Assessing the Impact of Crime on the Use of Imprisonment
Over the last 15 years imprisonment rates have declined in Europe on average by 15 percent and in the United States by 30 percent. Does this imply that, after decades long prison growth, we are facing a period of penal moderation? Since...
-
MICHAEL TONRY: ESCAPING AMERICAN PAROCHIALISM, CHAMPIONING COMPARATIVE RESEARCH AND REFORM
Michael Tonry’s life and work are an exception to American exceptionalism. His lifelong concern with American parochialism and antipathy to its punitiveness, racism, and historical lawlessness have led him to look beyond its borders for...
-
Comparing the Level of Punitiveness in the U.S. and Germany
The article discusses the factors that explain the substantial differences in imprisonment rates between Germany and the U.S.; starting point is Michael Tonry’s thesis that these differences ‘mostly reflect deliberate policy choices’....
-
Spatial dynamics of homicide in medieval English cities: the Medieval Murder Map project
This study examines the spatial patterns of homicide in three 14th-century English cities—London, York, and Oxford—through the Medieval Murder Map project, which visualizes 355 homicide cases derived from coroners’ inquests. Integrating...