Journal of Biogeography Экология

Biogeographical Domains Are Not Vegetation Types: Species Assignment Shapes Inference in Historical Biogeography

Marcus Vinicius Cianciaruso, Rosane Garcia Collevatti
Wiley · 2026-11-01 · DOI 10.1111/jbi.70425

Аннотация

ABSTRACT Rando et al. (2026) reconstruct the biogeographical history of Chamaecrista , proposing rainforest origins followed by diversification into open vegetation, with campos rupestres acting as a montane reservoir. We question these conclusions because their species assignments conflate biogeographical domains with vegetation types and produce an unbalanced representation across domains. The authors used species assigned to biogeographical domains as proxies for their predominant vegetation, then interpret the results as evidence of habitat shifts and vegetation‐associated adaptations. However, each domain encompasses multiple vegetation types, and species occurring within a domain are not necessarily associated with its predominant vegetation. Indeed, approximately 66% of the species assigned to the Amazon or Atlantic Forest domains and used as rainforest proxies occur in diverse vegetation types, including savannas and grasslands. These conceptual and classification issues introduce uncertainty into inferred dispersal events and the biogeographical history of Chamaecrista , potentially misleading interpretations of its evolutionary trajectories.

Читать у издателя →