BMC Medical Education Образование
Comparison between face-to-face and remote education based on academic performance and student satisfaction in a medical school
Аннотация
Background This study aimed to compare the academic performance of medical students undertaking face-to-face (FTF) and remote education and their satisfaction with these modes before and after the COVID-19 pandemic. Methods A comparative cross-sectional study was conducted on first-year medical students at Dankook University College of Medicine ( n = 212). Students were classified into three groups according to the study period: pre-pandemic (2018–2019, FTF, n = 73), pandemic (2020–2021, remote, n = 72), and post-pandemic (2022–2023, FTF, n = 67). We compared their academic performance across 14 school courses and the National Comprehensive Basic Medical Examination (NCBME). Class satisfaction was also assessed for these courses during each COVID-19 period using aggregated data. Regression analyses compared performance by period and teaching modality, adjusting for age, sex, high school type, admission type, and history of academic interruption. Results Performance was significantly higher during the pandemic than in the pre-pandemic period (β = 4.57, P < 0.0001), but not in the post-pandemic period. Overall, academic performance was better in remote education than in FTF education (β = 3.61, P = 0.0002). Scores on the National Comprehensive Basic Medical Examination did not differ by period or teaching modality after adjustment. Student satisfaction varied by course type. During the pandemic, satisfaction was higher in courses that did not require laboratory work and where instructors remained consistent. Conclusions Remote education did not appear to compromise standardized academic achievement, as measured by the NCBME, for first-year students of basic medical sciences. Higher course grades during the pandemic may reflect changes in assessment and grading practices rather than improved learning. However, diverse and well-designed online platforms may be necessary to improve student satisfaction, particularly in courses with laboratory components.