Biology & Philosophy Humanities and social sciences

Talking dog buttons: interspecies communication or illusion?

Sánchez-Moreno, Ignacio
Springer Nature · 2026-11-20 · DOI 10.1007/s10539-026-10033-9

Abstract

Anecdotal reports of dogs using talking buttons to convey requests, emotions, or even thoughts have gained considerable visibility on social media and sparked growing academic interest. Among the various criticisms concerning the use of Augmentative Interspecies Communication (AIC) systems with dogs, I consider the most problematic to be the claim that the behaviors observed do not constitute genuine instances of communication, but rather reflect conditioned responses produced through intensive training, an argument I refer to as the “training objection”. Although initially plausible, in this work I contend that this criticism relies on conceptually inadequate assumptions, specifically a reductionist perspective and the lack of clear criteria for identifying genuine communicative behaviors when using these devices. In this vein, I argue that the neo-Gricean framework of intentional communication provides the appropriate conceptual tools to distinguish communicative behaviors from non-communicative ones and that, moreover, it offers empirically testable indicators such as audience checking and persistence, which should be incorporated into experimental designs for assessing communicative intent in dogs using AIC systems such as talking buttons.

Read at publisher →