Artificial Intelligence Adoption in Indian Manufacturing SMEs: A Comprehensive Analysis of Drivers, Barriers, and Performance Outcomes
Abstract
This study examines AI adoption among Indian manufacturing SMEs using an integrated Technology-Organization-Environment (TOE) and Resource-Based View (RBV) framework. Through mixed-methods analysis of 450 SMEs and 25 executive interviews, we investigate adoption drivers, barriers, and performance outcomes. Results show 68% recognize AI’s importance, but only 34% have implemented solutions. Structural equation modeling reveals that technological readiness ( $$\beta $$ β = 0.42, $$p<$$ p < 0.001), organizational culture ( $$\beta $$ β = 0.38, $$p<$$ p < 0.001), and environmental factors ( $$\beta $$ β = 0.31, $$p<$$ p < 0.01) are significant predictors of AI adoption. Mediation analysis confirms that AI adoption mediates the relationship between TOE factors and performance outcomes (indirect effects ranging from 0.14 to 0.19, all $$p<$$ p < 0.05), with AI adoption serving as the mechanism through which TOE antecedents translate into organizational performance. Multi-group analysis reveals heterogeneous effects across firm sizes and industry sectors, with technology readiness more critical for larger firms and organizational culture more decisive for micro enterprises. We contribute an empirically grounded decision-support framework for staged AI implementation and investment prioritization, translating SEM findings into actionable heuristics for SME managers. AI adopters show significantly higher scores on operational efficiency (23% higher, $$p<$$ p < 0.001, Cohen’s d = 0.98) and competitive advantage (18% higher, $$p<$$ p < 0.001, Cohen’s d = 0.71) compared to non-adopters in cross-sectional analysis, consistent with the strategic value of systematic adoption approaches. This study investigates why Indian manufacturing small and medium enterprises (SMEs) adopt artificial intelligence (AI) and what happens to their performance when they do. We surveyed 450 SMEs and interviewed 25 senior executives across five states and five industry sectors. We find that while 68% of SMEs recognize AI as strategically important, only 34% have actually implemented it—a significant gap driven by technology readiness, organizational culture, and access to government support. Firms that have adopted AI score substantially higher on operational efficiency and competitive advantage than those that have not, though these are cross-sectional associations rather than causal effects. We also uncover a “dark side”: job displacement anxiety, vendor lock-in, and unauthorized AI use by employees are widespread and underappreciated risks. We translate our findings into a practical decision-support framework that helps SME managers prioritize investments and sequence implementation in three phases, with evidence-based readiness checkpoints at each stage.