Host-associated variation in ectomycorrhizal formation and function between Suillus luteus and two geographically contrasting pines
Abstract
Suillus species are important ectomycorrhizal fungi of Pinaceae, but the performance of a single Suillus strain may vary among compatible pine hosts. Pinus massoniana and P. tabuliformis are representative southern and northern Chinese pines, respectively, yet their responses to the same S. luteus strain remain poorly understood. To reduce soil-derived variation, seedlings were grown for 10 months in the same sterilized substrate with or without S. luteus inoculation. Ectomycorrhizas formed on both hosts, but colonization was higher in P. massoniana (70.0%) than in P. tabuliformis (47.5%). The two symbioses also differed morphologically: P. massoniana produced coralloid root tips with a thinner mantle and abundant extraradical hyphae, whereas P. tabuliformis formed mainly bifurcate root tips with a thicker mantle and fewer extraradical hyphae. Inoculation significantly increased seedling height, lateral root number, biomass, tissue N, P, and K concentrations, and rhizosphere enzyme activities in both hosts. However, P. massoniana showed a larger biomass-based mycorrhizal dependency, a stronger N response, and higher urease, laccase, peroxidase, and cellulase activities. These results show that, in this controlled experimental system, two compatible pine hosts differed in the establishment, morphology, and functional expression of symbiosis with the same S. luteus strain. Holding fungal strain and substrate constant reduced major environmental variation, but the generality of the pattern remains to be tested with additional fungal strains, host sources, nonsterile soils, and field or nursery validation.