Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society Catalysis

Expert and novice intuitive judgments about animal behavior

Renner, Michael J., Renner, Catherine Hackett
Springer Nature · 1993-06-01 · DOI 10.3758/bf03337350

Abstract

Although research in comparative psychology often relies on direct behavioral observation for data gathering, the influence of the observer is often overlooked. To study the effect of expertise on making judgments about behavior, novices and experts observed videotapes of rats from enriched and impoverished environments and attempted to determine each rat’s history. The judgment accuracy of all groups exceeded chance. Although experts used a broader vocabulary for describing the foundations of their judgments concerning animal behavior, novices were as accurate as experts at making the discrimination. Subjects were not able to correctly assess their own accuracy. The results of this study suggest that observer expertise does influence the data-gathering process in comparative psychology, but in indirect and often subtle ways.

Read at publisher →