Replacing fishmeal with insect proteins in aquafeeds: a global meta-analysis

Journal of Plant Biochemistry and Biotechnology · Springer Nature · 2026-11-14 · DOI: 10.1007/s12571-026-01735-9

Аннотация

As seafood demand rises and capture fisheries remain stagnant, aquaculture expands and consumes a large share of fishmeal (FM) supply, raising concerns over sustainability, cost, and food security. Insect-derived proteins are promising alternatives, but their effectiveness and scalability remain uncertain. We conducted a meta-analysis of 294 cases from 103 studies, covering 43 aquaculture species, nine insect meal types, and 27 countries. We quantified the effects of FM replacement on fish growth and flesh quality and identified key moderators. Overall, insect protein replacement did not significantly alter specific growth rate or feed conversion ratio, but substantial heterogeneity was detected across studies. Random forest modeling identified fish species, substitution rate, and dietary lipid level as the main drivers. Among the insect meals, black soldier fly (BSF) larvae meal emerged as the most promising because of its neutral effect on growth, limited competition with human food systems, broad evidence base, and potential to upcycle low-value side streams. Selectively bred strains showed a 14.5% growth advantage under FM replacement, although this may largely reflect general genetic gain rather than diet-specific adaptation. Integrating BSF meal with selective breeding, nutrient supplementation, ingredient processing, and precision formulation may progressively reduce or potentially eliminate FM use, while redirecting part of the underlying marine protein resource, equivalent to approximately 3 million tonnes globally, toward higher-value uses. However, limited supply, high costs, nutritional trade-offs, and scarce evidence for diet-specific breeding constrain full replacement, highlighting an urgent need for further research investment and supportive policies to accelerate development and adoption.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи