Agroforestry Systems Лесное хозяйство
Soil organic carbon and tree productivity responses to intercropping in tree-based agroecosystems: a global meta-analysis under different climate zones and soil textural classes
Аннотация
Tree-based agroecosystems can contribute to soil carbon accumulation while supporting agricultural production, but the effects of intercropping on soil organic carbon (SOC) and tree productivity remain variable across environmental conditions and intercrop types. This study conducted a global multilevel meta-analysis of 63 field-based studies to quantify intercropping effects on SOC and tree productivity and examine the influence of intercrop functional group, climate, and soil texture. Intercropping significantly increased SOC (ln response ratio [lnRR] = 0.1767, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.1038–0.2495, p < 0.0001). The subgroup estimates indicated SOC increases of 15.7% under leguminous intercrops (lnRR = 0.1456) and 9.0% under non-leguminous intercrops (lnRR = 0.0858). In contrast, the overall response of tree productivity was not statistically significant (lnRR = − 0.0792, 95% CI − 0.2307 to 0.0723, p = 0.3056). Although productivity estimates were positive under both leguminous (lnRR = 0.1541; 16.7%) and non-leguminous intercrops (lnRR = 0.1145; 12.1%), only the leguminous subgroup showed a statistically significant response. Climate significantly moderated SOC responses (QM = 27.5808, df = 3, p < 0.0001), with the largest effect observed in arid regions (lnRR = 0.2962). Soil texture was also a significant moderator (QM = 30.1376, df = 12, p = 0.0027), with positive SOC responses in clay, loamy clay, sandy loam, and silty loam soils. No significant climate- or soil-texture-specific effects were detected for tree productivity. Sensitivity analyses were used to assess the robustness of the findings to imputed standard deviations and selected moderator categories. The results indicate that intercropping can improve SOC in tree-based agroecosystems, but a consistent effect on tree productivity was not established. These findings highlight the importance of integrating climatic conditions, soil properties, and intercrop functional groups into tree management strategies to enhance soil carbon sequestration, sustain tree productivity, and promote the long-term environmental sustainability and resilience of tree-based agroecosystems.