European Journal of Law and Economics Law
Court resolution and predictive justice
Abstract
This article examines the impact of predictive justice on litigants’ decisions in French divorce cases. Court backlog is a persistent issue, and predictive justice tools aim to facilitate out-of-court settlements by informing litigants about the likely judicial outcome. We conducted a laboratory experiment in which pairs of subjects—one representing the claimant and the other the defendant—negotiated over alimony payments across three rounds. If no agreement was reached, the case was decided by a judge and legal costs were imposed. Depending on the treatment, one or both parties received information from a predictive justice algorithm. Contrary to expectations, providing information to the claimant or to both parties reduced the likelihood of reaching an out-of-court settlement, a pattern consistent with both parties initially underestimating the likely judicial award. However, when settlements did occur, the alimony amounts were closer to those that the judge would have awarded, suggesting that predictive justice can improve the legal accuracy of agreements even as it decreases their frequency. Our experiment thus reveals a trade-off between increasing settlement rates and enhancing the legal accuracy of negotiated outcomes.