Educational technology research and development Education

Matching minds and materials: the interplay of learner support and learner characteristics

Tulea, Cristina, Scheller, Nadine, Endres, Tino, Schneider, Sascha
Springer Nature · 2026-11-04 · DOI 10.1007/s11423-026-10750-8

Abstract

Prior knowledge is a central cognitive factor shaping how learners benefit from instructional support in digital learning environments. Pretraining and worked-out examples are known as single support strategies for activating or building prior knowledge and facilitating the integration of new knowledge. The interaction between prior knowledge and single support strategies has been widely studied. Yet the use of single support strategies does not reflect actual teaching practice, in which multiple forms of instructional support are tailored to learners’ characteristics so that all students can benefit effectively from instruction. This study examines the potential interaction between prior knowledge and the instructional support strategies of pretraining and worked-out examples, which can be applied sequentially when teaching adaptively. A total of 139 primary school students were randomly assigned to one of the four conditions in a 2 (pretraining vs. no pretraining) × 2 (partially vs. fully worked-out example) between-subjects factorial design, with prior knowledge as a moderator. Cognitive load and learning outcomes are examined. Results show that prior knowledge moderates learning outcomes, with lower prior knowledge learners profiting from both pretraining and worked-out examples. The higher the learners’ prior knowledge, the greater the effect shifted from positive to nonsignificant to negative. A significant three-way interaction emerged, indicating that the design of digital learning environments depends not only on learners’ prior knowledge but also on the combined influence of multiple support strategies. Practical implications point to the design of adaptive, technology-enhanced learning environments that dynamically tailor pretraining and worked-out examples to learners’ evolving knowledge states.

Read at publisher →