Tree Genetics & Genomes Biological sciences

Selection of phenotypically superior individuals and paternity reconstruction in open-pollinated Betula platyphylla progenies based on the BWB strategy

Wen, Haoyu, Zhang, Jie, Dong, Linlin, Jiang, Jing, Li, Huiyu
Springer Nature · 2026-10-29 · DOI 10.1007/s11295-026-01764-7

Abstract

This study aimed to apply the Breeding Without Breeding (BWB) strategy to the genetic improvement of Betula platyphylla Suk. by integrating multi-trait phenotypic selection with retrospective molecular pedigree reconstruction of open-pollinated progeny. A total of 695 open-pollinated progeny from 18 maternal families were initially analyzed under the maternal half-sib assumption because paternal identities were unknown. A multi-trait selection index was constructed based on tree height, diameter at breast height (DBH), volume, and stem straightness. Individuals were selected at a 20% selection intensity, resulting in 139 phenotypically selected individuals. These individuals were subsequently genotyped together with 18 maternal trees and 43 candidate paternal trees. Fifteen polymorphic simple sequence repeat (SSR) loci were screened from 200 primer pairs developed based on the B. platyphylla genome. Genotyping was conducted using direct fluorescent-labeled SSR markers combined with capillary electrophoresis. Population genetic parameters were calculated, and paternity analysis was conducted using the Delta statistic implemented in CERVUS 3.0.7. A total of 139 phenotypically selected individuals were obtained. Their tree height, DBH , and volume increased by 12.57%, 32.73%, and 68.70%, respectively, compared to the family means, with the genetic gain for volume reaching 13.26%. Across the 15 SSR loci, 113 alleles were detected, with a mean number of alleles ( Na ) of 7.53 and a mean polymorphism information content ( PIC ) of 0.54, indicating high polymorphism. The cumulative probability of exclusion ( CPE ) under different known parental conditions all approached 100%. Among the 136 offspring evaluated using the known-mother model, 103 (75.74%) were assigned a unique candidate father at the 95% strict confidence level (simulated Delta threshold = 0.00), while 33 remained unresolved. These same 103 assignments were equally supported at the 80% relaxed confidence level, confirming consistent resolution under the Delta criterion. Four parental combinations that were repeatedly represented among the 103 confidence-supported assignments (♀17×♂18, ♀28×♂18, ♀29×♂18, and ♀38×♂13) were retained for further validation. These paternal representations describe only the distribution of assigned paternal identities among the phenotypically selected offspring and should not be interpreted as measures of reproductive success, relative paternal contribution, or genetic merit in the seed orchard. This study demonstrates the feasibility of integrating multi-trait phenotypic selection with molecular pedigree reconstruction in B. platyphylla and provides a framework for characterizing paternal representation among phenotypically selected progeny. The identified parental combinations may serve as materials for further validation through controlled crossing and progeny testing, rather than as evidence of superior parental performance or as a direct basis for seed orchard optimization.

Read at publisher →