Open Economies Review Экономика и эконометрика
China’s Reciprocal Response to Foreign Carbon Border Adjustments: Output Buffering, Welfare Trade-offs, and Carbon Leakage
Аннотация
This paper examines whether China can deploy reciprocal carbon tariffs to offset the macroeconomic losses from foreign border carbon adjustments without worsening national welfare. We build a multi-region, multi-sector GTAP-E model, update GTAP 10 from 2014 to a 2025 baseline, and compare three model variants: Standard GTAP-E, a Carbon-Factor ablation, and the full Carbon-Factor extension. The enacted EU CBAM serves as the policy benchmark; coordinated US and Japanese participation enters only as a structured stress test. In the EU_Core benchmark, reciprocity narrows China’s GDP loss from − 0.221% to -0.187% but reduces equivalent variation from − 8,420.50 to -9,015.24 million US dollars. The same GDP–welfare divergence intensifies in the EUUSJPN_All upper-bound stress test, where GDP improves from − 1.228% to -1.131% while equivalent variation falls from − 52,816.95 to -53,613.15 million US dollars because allocative-efficiency losses exceed terms-of-trade gains. Model-increment validation confirms that this trade-off stems from the activated Carbon-Factor channel, not from benchmark relabeling. Broader coverage deepens abatement but raises leakage and marginal abatement costs. Green-technology revenue recycling outperforms lump-sum transfers, supporting only narrow and conditional reciprocity under current EU policy.