Journal for STEM Education Research Образование

The Effects of Learner Choice and Concept Map Format on Student Learning Outcomes in Undergraduate STEM Education

Sunday, Oluwafemi J., Jin, Gan, Ajeigbe, Oluwafemi J.
Springer Nature · 2026-07-01 · DOI 10.1007/s41979-026-00191-6

Аннотация

This classroom-based experimental study investigated how learner choice and concept map format influence undergraduate students’ conceptual learning in an introductory chemistry course. While prior research has examined the effects of instructional choice on motivation and learning, little is known about how choice interacts with cognitively demanding tasks such as concept mapping in STEM settings. Grounded in Generative Learning Theory, Self-Determination Theory, and the ICAP Framework, we employed a 2 (choice vs. no-choice) × 3 (concept map format: translation, fill-in-the-blank, correction) factorial design, with perceived competence as a covariate. A total of 529 students completed concept map activities, followed by retention and transfer assessments. Results revealed significant main effects of both choice and concept map format on retention: students who selected their preferred activity achieved higher scores, and map translation format produced the strongest outcomes. For transfer, only concept map format yielded a significant effect, with map translation associated with the highest adjusted means, while choice alone did not influence transfer. These findings suggest that autonomy-supportive instructional design enhances retention when paired with cognitively demanding tasks, yet scaffolding may be necessary to extend benefits to knowledge transfer. Implications for the design of STEM instruction highlight the importance of aligning autonomy with competence-supportive, generative learning activities to foster deeper conceptual understanding.

Читать у издателя →