Comparative numerical assessment of SPH, EFG, and SPG methods for orthogonal cutting of steel
Аннотация
Orthogonal cutting of steel involves severe plastic deformation, high strain rates, and localised heating–conditions that make quantitative numerical prediction challenging. This study presents a systematic, fully controlled comparison of three mesh-free methods—Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH), Element-Free Galerkin (EFG), and Smoothed Particle Galerkin (SPG)—implemented in LS-DYNA under identical Johnson–Cook constitutive parameters (A = 553 MPa, B = 601 MPa, n = 0.234, C = 0.0134, m = 1.0, Tm = 1480 °C), boundary conditions, and nodal distance (0.40 mm). SPG predicts the main cutting force with an average deviation of 2.2% from experimental data (vs. 6.5% for EFG and 8.1% for SPH) and achieves the lowest force oscillation (CV = 4.2% vs. 6.8% and 15.3%). The strong correlation between equivalent plastic strain and temperature confirms physically consistent thermomechanical coupling in SPG. A bond-based damage criterion (FS = 0.2) enables natural chip separation without external fracture tracking, in contrast to EFG (no intrinsic fracture) and SPH (tensile instability). Drawing on the cutting speed ratio concept of Ling et al. (J Manuf Process, 119:68–82) for vibration-assisted cutting, we define an effective separation ratio $${k}_{eff}$$ for each method: SPG exhibits $${k}_{\text{e}\text{f}\text{f}}\approx 0.67$$, indicative of a near-separated cutting regime that reduces forces and improves surface quality, whereas SPH and EFG operate in the near-continuous regime ($$k_{{{\text{eff}}}} \approx 0.9 - 1.0$$). SPG is recommended as the most reliable mesh-free framework for industrial machining simulations involving large deformation and fracture.