A Framework for SDG Evaluation Integrating 2-Tuple Linguistic Aggregation with Choquet Capacities and Deck-of-Cards Elicitation: Methodology and Decision Support Tool
Аннотация
Evaluating Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) requires integrating heterogeneous expert judgments across qualitative sustainability dimensions—a task for which traditional numerical frameworks cause information loss and representational bias. We propose a heterogeneous fuzzy linguistic model (HFLM) based on the 2-tuple linguistic representation model and the Computing with Words (CWW) paradigm and present a decision support tool implementing it end-to-end. The framework supports three aggregation levels: expert assessments are consolidated per criterion via 2-tuple weighted average or ordered weighted averaging (OWA) operators; criterion results are combined into a global evaluation via a Choquet integral governed by a 2-additive capacity, capturing non-additive SDG interactions. The capacity is built from fuzzy densities obtained through a structured Deck-of-Cards (Simos–Roy–Figueira) protocol together with pairwise interaction terms from targeted specialist judgement. The framework is first verified computationally against analytical baselines, then subjected to a controlled simulation experiment under a factorial design, and finally illustrated through a fully synthetic case study—a simulated 50-expert multidisciplinary panel evaluating Internet of Things (IoT)-enabled healthcare for ageing populations (SDG 3)—designed to test its mathematical robustness, heterogeneity handling, and discriminative capacity under controlled conditions. The results show that the Choquet aggregation identifies Rural Connectivity as the structural bottleneck of the synthetic scenario and quantifies its amplification, displacing the global score below every weighted-average baseline without requiring the blanket pessimism of an OWA operator, while the tool is designed to make this discriminative capacity accessible to practitioners without specialist knowledge of the formalism.