Stochastic Absolute Reference Method for Multi-Expert Evaluation of Shipping Lines Selection Factors

Nguyen, Thuy-Trang, Nguyen, Van-Hop
Operations Research Forum · Springer Nature · 2026-10-10 · DOI: 10.1007/s43069-026-00705-3

Abstract

In complex environments with incomplete information, multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) techniques, such as analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and best worst method (BWM), are widely applied based on decision makers’ preferences. However, both methods face challenges in fluctuating environments where criteria or alternatives frequently change, or criteria weightings vary significantly. To reduce decision-making workloads in such dynamic scenarios, this study proposes a novel approach, namely the absolute reference method (ARM). A consistency formulation for ARM is also developed, applicable to different measurement scales and extendable to assess consistency in the linear BWM. To validate the proposed ARM and its consistency formulation, some illustrative examples are provided. Furthermore, a simulation experiment was conducted with a controlled number of criteria and varying levels of input inconsistency. The empirical results indicate that ARM achieved a significantly lower average deviation (0.274), measured by the mean square error between the comparison inputs and their derived weight ratios, outperforming both the BWM (0.389) and the AHP (0.436), equivalent to 29.6% and 37.2% reductions, respectively. Finally, to demonstrate its applicability, the multi-expert stochastic ARM is conducted to assess factors influencing shipping line service selection in Vietnam, addressing a situation where the weighting activity is affected by various opinions of different experts. Maritime shipping is crucial for the global supply chain and international trade, where competition among carriers has been intensifying. Identifying critical factors affecting customers’ choice of shipping services and determining their relative importance are essential for companies operating in the maritime logistics sector.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles