Home Production and Technology: Why Time-Saving Innovations Do Not Always Save Time
Аннотация
Firms and policymakers routinely promote time-saving technologies on the assumption that they reduce the time households devote to home production. Yet a century of labor-saving household appliances reduced housework time only modestly, while newer innovations such as on-demand food delivery show more consistent time savings. The divergence reflects a distinction that existing frameworks do not typically make explicit. The relevant question is not whether a technology saves time, but which component of the household production problem it affects. Efficiency-improving technologies raise demand for home-produced goods, but their effect on total housework time is ambiguous because the induced increase in home-good consumption may be smaller than, equal to, or larger than the direct reduction in time required per unit. Technologies that lower the full price of market substitutes, which combine the money outlay with the time a household must spend obtaining the good, tend to produce more systematic substitution away from home production when the compensated composition effect outweighs the accompanying aggregate-demand response. This paper develops a simple household production framework that formalizes this distinction and illustrates the mechanisms using three contemporary technologies, namely robotic cleaning devices, food delivery platforms, and meal kit services. The American Time Use Survey series covering 2003–2019 and 2021–2024 illustrates the divergent time-use patterns that the framework is designed to organize. The framework implies that a technology’s time effect depends on the parameter it changes. Reductions in the full price of market alternatives reduce home-production time when the elasticity of substitution exceeds the aggregate demand elasticity, whereas the effect of a pure home-production efficiency improvement is generally ambiguous.