Medical Science Educator Образование

Examiner Characteristics and Interexaminer Variability in OSCE Scoring at an Offshore Medical University: A Retrospective Analysis of History-Taking and Physical-Examination Domains

Calton, Rakesh
Springer Nature · 2026-12-01 · DOI 10.1007/s40670-026-02923-0

Аннотация

Interexaminer variability threatens the fairness of objective structured clinical examinations (OSCEs), but it is unclear whether such variability is uniform across assessment domains or concentrated where examiner judgment is most inferential, and evidence from offshore medical schools is scarce. This retrospective, cross-sectional study analyzed archival records from the January to April 2025 OSCEs at an offshore, for-profit medical university: 605 preclinical students in Semesters 2 to 5 and the 23 examiners who scored them. History-taking scores, assessed with items common to every case, and physical-examination scores, assessed with system-specific items, were analyzed separately using fixed-effects factorial analyses of variance that included four examiner characteristics, three student characteristics, and their two-way interactions. For history taking, examiner race or ethnicity ( p = .010) and professional seniority ( p = .036) were significant, as was an examiner gender by race or ethnicity interaction ( p = .041). For physical examination, no main effect was significant, and only an interaction between examiner OSCE experience and student age reached significance ( p = .037). No student characteristic predicted scores in either domain, and all effects were small (partial η ² ≤ 0.017). Examiner-related variability was therefore concentrated in history taking and persisted even though every examiner completed a case-specific calibration session before scoring. Because the examiner pool was small and drawn mainly from two racial or ethnic groups, the demographic findings should be regarded as hypothesis-generating.

Читать у издателя →