Pastoral Psychology Социология и политология

Kenotic Disposition, Transference, and Countertransference in Christian Spiritual Care and Psychotherapy

Ishag, Shereen
Springer Nature · 2026-11-11 · DOI 10.1007/s11089-026-01387-8

Аннотация

This article examines how the theological understanding of kenotic disposition can inform the psychodynamic theory of transference and countertransference within Christian spiritual care. Drawing on biblical and patristic thought, contemporary kenotic theology, and psychoanalytic theory from Freud through relational psychoanalysis, it argues that the humility, self-emptying love, and relational holding at the heart of kenosis offer spiritual caregivers a theological account of what psychoanalysis names the containment and use of countertransference. The article has five sections. First, it briefly traces the theological foundations of kenosis from Philippians 2 through the patristic tradition to contemporary voices including Coakley, Balthasar, and Papanikolaou. Second, it surveys the psychoanalytic development of transference and countertransference from Freud through Winnicott, Bion, Mitchell, and Benjamin. Third, it develops a constructive framework in which the kenotic disposition functions as a spiritual caregiver’s formation for the work of transference. Fourth, it shows how the virtues and practices of the Christian ascetic and contemplative tradition cultivate this disposition and expand precisely the capacities (non-retaliation, containment, self-awareness, and self-giving held within firm limits) that the clinical literature asks caregivers to have. Fifth, it names the limits of this proposed framework, using Ghent’s contrast between surrender and submission to make a clear distinction between nourishing self-emptying and harmful self-negation and arguing that professional boundaries and kenotic humility are mutually reinforcing rather than opposing frameworks.

Читать у издателя →