Entrepreneurial vigilance: Literature review (bibliometric analysis)
Аннотация
Entrepreneurial alertness is a cornerstone of opportunity identification. However, the related, yet distinct, concept of entrepreneurial vigilance which encompasses the proactive behaviors and preparatory actions that precede opportunity exploitation remains conceptually vague and empirically underdeveloped. This study aims to clearly delineate entrepreneurial vigilance from alertness and provide a comprehensive overview of its evolution, key components, and research frontiers. This study employs a systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis. Following a structured three-phase framework, we analyzed 931 articles (1983–2024) from Google Scholar. The analysis includes citation analysis, co-citation mapping using VOSviewer, and a thematic synthesis to identify the core, measurable dimensions of vigilance. We establish a clear conceptual distinction: while alertness is a cognitive capability which is innate or developed ability to notice opportunities (Kirzner, 1973), vigilance is a broader, multi-dimensional process encompassing proactive information scanning, association, evaluation, and the preparatory behaviors that precede entrepreneurial action. The bibliometric analysis reveals a significant surge in publications since 2006, with key contributors like Tang, Baron, and Busenitz shaping the field. We identify six core antecedents of vigilance: personality traits, communication, prior experience, environmental munificence, digital competences, and social networks. The post-2020 literature increasingly emphasizes the role of artificial intelligence, big data analytics, and digital platforms as amplifiers of vigilant behaviors. Crucially, we find that empirical validation remains scarce, with only 3.65% of studies offering formal empirical testing, highlighting a significant gap between theoretical development and practical measurement. This research offers three key contributions: (1) it provides a clear, operationalizable conceptual demarcation between entrepreneurial alertness and vigilance, resolving a long-standing ambiguity; (2) it presents the first bibliometric mapping of the field, visualizing its intellectual structure and evolution; (3) it proposes an integrated conceptual model of vigilance as a behavioral process, incorporating emerging digital dimensions; and (4) it offers a specific research agenda for future empirical investigation.