Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology Law
Influential Factors in Perceptions of the Wrongfully Convicted: Gender, Contributing Factor, and Housing
Abstract
While legal exoneration serves as a formal declaration of innocence, the social reintegration of exonerees is often hindered by persistent public stigma. This study examined how exoneree gender (male vs. female), housing status (death row vs. general population), and the primary contributing factor to the conviction (eyewitness misidentification vs. faulty forensics vs. informant testimony vs. false confession) influenced perceptions. Participants ( N = 538) read a mock news article detailing a wrongful conviction and then reported their perceived guilt, social distance, and overall perceptions. Contrary to hypotheses, there was no effect of exoneree gender or housing status on any of the dependent variables; however, a robust main effect of the contributing factor emerged across all measures. Specifically, exonerees who falsely confessed were perceived as significantly more guilty and more negatively compared to all other conditions. Furthermore, a relationship emerged that indicated that a lingering belief in an individual’s guilt, despite being exonerated, directly decreased their perceived social acceptance. These findings identify a false confession penalty in the public consciousness. Unlike systemic errors (e.g., faulty forensics), false confessions appear to create a psychological anchor of culpability that legal exoneration does not fully mitigate. This suggests that exonerees whose cases involve self-incrimination face unique heightened barriers to social reintegration, necessitating targeted advocacy and public education regarding the psychology of false confessions.