Education and Information Technologies Library and Information Sciences
Beyond the dashboard: co-designing actionable learning analytics for primary education
Abstract
Learning Analytics dashboards (LADs) are widely promoted for enhancing instructional decision-making, yet they continue to fall short of teachers’ needs and classroom realities. Despite calls for human-centred design to address such necessity, evidence on sustained teacher involvement across the design process is limited, and little is understood about how teachers conceptualise pedagogically meaningful data or negotiate control in analytics-supported instruction. This study investigates how teachers can be engaged as pedagogical co-designers in the development of an LAD designed as a “hub LAD” integrating student data from multiple educational systems for Maths in primary education. We conducted a multi-phase qualitative phenomenological study involving six Dutch primary school Math teachers. The multi-phase process involved interviews, design-thinking workshops and sketching activities for brainstorming, conceptualisation and initial evaluation of a low-fidelity prototype. Findings reveal challenges related to fragmented data and limited visibility into student learning, reflecting a misalignment between what LADs present and the pedagogical, social, and contextual knowledge teachers draw upon. Teachers articulated a demand for action-oriented analytics beyond performance indicators to include socio-emotional, behavioural and analogue dimensions of learning, challenging assumptions about what counts as legitimate pedagogical data. Three core design requirements emerged: (1) monitoring and alerting, (2) pedagogically grounded student clustering, and (3) advisory decision-support that preserve teacher autonomy. These revealed relational stances toward automation, forming a typology of teacher-LAD relationship in which LAD automation and teacher control is situationally negotiated. The current study advances understanding of how sustained co-design can reshape LADs toward pedagogically meaningful, context-sensitive, and action-oriented educational solutions. Practitioner Notes What is already known about this topic Teacher-facing Learning Analytics dashboards (LADs) often focus on performance metrics, providing limited support for broader pedagogical interpretation and action. Human-centred Design seems crucial for bridging research on Learning Analytics and teacher practice, but teacher involvement often remains limited to early brainstorming. There is still a need for further empirical evidence on human-centred design in LADs. What this paper adds A typology of teacher-LAD relationship, showing that teachers' preferences on AI automation preferred automation level is are situational, shaped by time, trust, and instructional stakes. Teachers’ need of integrating socioemotional, cognitive, and analogue data on LADs, reflecting a broader claim about what counts as actionable evidence. Empirical evidence on a sustained co-design process, under Human-centred Design, supporting teachers to conceptualise, prioritise, and evaluate LAD features across the LAD design. Implications for practice and/or policy Holistic student models, including socioemotional and relational data (i.e., student-student and student-teacher relationships), to enhance teachers’ understanding of student needs and to broaden the pedagogical relevance of LADs. Human-centred Design, while time-consuming, often requires iterative processes of different design sessions to permit teachers’ deeper reflections.