Paired comparison methods play a fundamental role in decision-making, preference elicitation, and data evaluation. While the concept of consistency is well established in pairwise comparison matrices-based models, the stochastic models, including Thurstone-motivated models, have remained less explored in this regard. This paper extends the notion of consistency in a groundbreaking way to two- and three-option Thurstone-motivated models, as well as Davidson’s model, establishing connections between the two-option Bradley-Terry, the three-option Davidson’s model, and pairwise comparison matrices-based models through equivalence statements. These statements are the basis for an alternative definition of consistency, valid for general two- and three-option stochastic paired comparison models. Based on this definition we also define a data inconsistency index to quantify deviations from ideal consistency because the consistent data sets are very rare. We formulated a set of axioms for data inconsistency indices and proved that they are independent and form a consistent axiomatic system. We also showed that the proposed inconsistency index satisfies all of these axioms. Based on random simulations, we illustrate its further properties. These results provide a unified framework for the assessment of consistency, paving the way for future developments of formal inconsistency indices.
Tóth-Merényi, Anna, Mihálykó, Csaba, Orbán-Mihálykó, Éva. Investigating the concept of consistency and an inconsistency index in two- and three-option stochastic paired comparison models. // Central European Journal of Operations Research. – 2026. – DOI: 10.1007/s10100-026-01045-7. – URL: http://link.springer.com/openurl/fulltext?id=doi:10.1007/s10100-026-01045-7
Tóth-Merényi, Anna, Mihálykó, Csaba, Orbán-Mihálykó, & Éva (2026). Investigating the concept of consistency and an inconsistency index in two- and three-option stochastic paired comparison models. Central European Journal of Operations Research. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10100-026-01045-7
Tóth-Merényi, et al. “Investigating the concept of consistency and an inconsistency index in two- and three-option stochastic paired comparison models.” Central European Journal of Operations Research, 2026. doi:10.1007/s10100-026-01045-7.
@article{TthMernyi2026,
title = {Investigating the concept of consistency and an inconsistency index in two- and three-option stochastic paired comparison models},
author = {Tóth-Merényi and Anna and Mihálykó and Csaba and Orbán-Mihálykó and Éva},
journal = {Central European Journal of Operations Research},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.1007/s10100-026-01045-7},
url = {http://link.springer.com/openurl/fulltext?id=doi:10.1007/s10100-026-01045-7}
}
In this paper, we consider cost-sharing problems defined on rooted trees. We refer to these problems as cost-tree problems and to the induced transferable utility cooperative games as irrigation games. We introduce a formal notion of...
In this paper, we focus on nonlinear programming problems with cardinality constraints that restrict the number of nonzero components of the decision vector. We start with a straightforward mixed-integer programming reformulation....
Portfolio selection is a critical issue in financial management under uncertainty. In this paper, we propose a complex approach for portfolio selection with quantile return approximation. In particular, we propose a practical workflow...
The transcendental logarithmic (translog) production function is recognised as a flexible functional form for modelling production processes. It accommodates varying elasticities of input substitution and diverse types of...
This study investigates mothership-drone route determination using two optimization approaches: a Mixed Integer Linear Programming (MILP) model based on a discrete hexagonal grid, and a Mixed Integer Nonlinear Programming (MINLP) model...