Using Shannon’s Entropy to Quantify Preference Heterogeneity in Large Populations with Complete Preorders
Аннотация
Understanding how much a group of individuals disagrees in their preferences is a fundamental problem in collective decision-making. When the number of participants and available options is large, measuring this disagreement rigorously and efficiently becomes particularly demanding. The present study addresses this challenge by introducing a formally grounded measure of preference heterogeneity for large-scale group decision-making settings, in which individual preferences are expressed as complete rankings over a set of alternatives, allowing for ties. The proposed measure is derived from Shannon’s entropy and quantifies the degree of diversity in the distribution of individual preferences across a group. A value of zero indicates full agreement, whereas higher values reflect greater dispersion of opinions. The measure is shown to satisfy a set of desirable normative properties drawn from Social Choice Theory, including anonymity, neutrality, and conditions governing how heterogeneity changes when the group or the set of alternatives is modified. An axiomatic characterisation establishes that the proposed measure is the unique index satisfying these properties jointly. The computational simplicity of the measure makes it applicable to very large populations without loss of tractability. Its practical performance is evaluated through ten real-world ranked-choice elections from a publicly available preference database, encompassing electorates of up to nearly three hundred thousand voters and up to eleven candidates. Simulation experiments conducted under diverse probabilistic scenarios further confirm the robustness and sensitivity of the measure to variations in preference dispersion.