Medical Science Educator Education

Becoming a Doctor Together: Collaborative Learning as a Mediational Space for Professional Identity Formation in Medical Education

Cragno, Alejandro G., Cubero-Pérez, Rosario
Springer Nature · 2026-12-01 · DOI 10.1007/s40670-026-02933-y

Abstract

Professional identity formation has become a concern in medical education, within sociocultural perspectives emphasizing participation, interaction, and meaning-making. Although collaborative learning is used in undergraduate curricula, its role in shaping identity trajectories, especially during early training, remains insufficiently understood. This study explored how medical students in early stages of an integrated curriculum based on collaborative learning construct and narrate their identities as learners and future professionals. We conducted a qualitative study within an interpretive paradigm using focus groups with 45 students transitioning from preclinical to clinical training. Data were analyzed following grounded theory principles through iterative coding, constant comparison, and category development. Students described collaborative learning as a cross-cutting element shaping both how they learned and who they were becoming. Four dimensions were identified: perception of the curriculum, knowledge construction in groups, personal transformation as learners, and professional projection. Across these dimensions, identity development emerged as a dynamic, tension-laden process characterized by negotiation, adaptation, and narrative reconstruction. Collaborative learning environments functioned not only as spaces for cognitive interdependence but also as contexts in which students were recognized as participants in a community of practice and constructed continuity between past experiences, present participation, and future professional aspirations. These findings suggest that collaborative learning can be understood as a mediational space for professional identity formation, where becoming a doctor is shaped through collective practices and narrative processes. This perspective extends sociocultural understandings of identity by showing that learning together is central not only to what students know, but to who they become. Collaborative learning functions as a key sociocultural mediator in the construction of medical students’ professional identity. Early exposure to situated clinical and community-based learning supports students’ transition from learner to future physician. Students associate group learning dynamics with the development of empathy and interdisciplinary collaboration. Students’ narrative trajectories reveal meaningful links between current academic practices and projected professional commitment. The study provides evidence to inform integrated curriculum design in undergraduate medical education in Latin America.

Read at publisher →