Body shifted, soul not: migrant identity, social inclusion, and small business success
Аннотация
Migrant entrepreneurs who feel at home in their adopted country get more out of their cultural roots, while those who feel excluded get less. Using survey data from 364 migrant business owners across Spain, France, Italy, and the UK, we find that strong attachment to one’s country of origin is linked to better business performance, especially when entrepreneurs also feel socially accepted in the host society. For migrants who experience exclusion, the same home-country identification offers little benefit and can even become a drag on performance. These findings suggest that integration policy has economic as well as social benefits: inclusive host environments unlock the entrepreneurial potential embedded in migrants’ cultural identities, while exclusionary ones suppress it. Policymakers and support organizations seeking to maximize the economic contribution of migrant entrepreneurship should therefore invest as seriously in perceived social inclusion as in business development programs. Why do some migrant entrepreneurs succeed while others, equally embedded in the same structural conditions, do not? We argue that the answer lies partly in psychology: in how migrants identify with their home and host countries, and in whether, in the migrant’s opinion, the host society recognizes and accepts this self-identification. Drawing on role transition theory and survey data from 364 migrant entrepreneurs across four Western European countries, we find that home-country attachment positively predicts business performance, but the strength of this relationship depends on perceived social inclusion in the host society. When migrants feel socially included, strong home-country identification becomes a significant performance asset. When they feel excluded, this advantage disappears and may even turn into a liability. Perceived inclusion itself has no direct effect on performance; rather, it shapes whether and to what extent identity orientation translates into performance outcomes. These findings reveal that entrepreneurial success among migrants is shaped not only by structural conditions but also by how migrants identify themselves and how they perceive that identity being received.