Higher Education Education

Beyond “one size fits all”: graduate satisfaction across academic fields

Llach, Josep, Casadesús, Martí
Springer Nature · 2026-10-24 · DOI 10.1007/s10734-026-01782-3

Abstract

Graduate satisfaction surveys are widely used in higher education quality assurance, yet common measurement frameworks often assume that the same dimensions of the student experience carry similar relevance across academic fields. This study examines how Teaching and Learning, Student Support, and Learning Outcomes relate to overall graduate satisfaction and whether these relationships vary systematically by academic field. The analysis draws on the Catalan Graduate Satisfaction Survey (2018–2023) and includes 2,993 programme-year observations from Bachelor’s programmes across five fields: Arts and Humanities, Social and Legal Sciences, Sciences, Health Sciences, and Engineering and Architecture. Panel data models are used to examine both overall and field-specific patterns. All three dimensions are positively related to graduate satisfaction in the full sample, but their relative importance varies across fields. Teaching and Learning emerges as the strongest dimension overall and shows significantly larger coefficients in all four other fields than in Engineering and Architecture, with the largest differences in Arts and Humanities and Sciences. Student Support displays a more field-specific pattern: it is statistically significant within Social and Legal Sciences and Engineering and Architecture, while comparative tests identify significant differences relative to Engineering and Architecture only for Arts and Humanities and Health Sciences. Learning Outcomes remain comparatively stable, with no statistically significant cross-field differences. These findings distinguish measurement comparability from interpretive equivalence. Common satisfaction dimensions can support system-wide comparison without assuming that they relate to overall satisfaction in the same way across academic fields. A field-sensitive approach therefore retains a common measurement core while interpreting the relative importance of its dimensions in relation to academic field, with implications for both quality assurance and educational enhancement.

Read at publisher →